They do it a lot. Narratives indicate that gentrification and urban planning led to social isolation and loss of social support networks among men in the sex industry. Another worker described why his preference is to solicit online, particularly in regard to the heightened risks associated with working on the street. The available literature, based on research conducted primarily in higher income settings i.
A key element of the present study is the active co-leadership and involvement of community members and partners throughout the research process. Interviews lasted approximately 1.
Drawing on a socioecological framework, thematic analysis of interview transcripts was conducted utilizing ATLAS. However, this research has almost exclusively been drawn from women sex workers Shannon et al. Eligibility included being 19 years of age or older, self-identifying as a man, and buying or selling sex within the past year. Coinciding with this gentrification was a shift to online sex work, which many participants describe as creating heightened competition among workers and social isolation. One participant explains the atmosphere on the streets of Vancouver for men sex workers:.
But law criminalizes the advertisement and purchase of sexual services jeopardizing security
And I only started doing that because they shut [Boystown] down. Like jack your name up.
Recent legal reforms in Canada to further criminalize sex work raise ificant concern for human rights and health of individuals in the sex industry, and point to the critical need to include voices of men and trans sex escorts and buyers in policy discussions.
This latter point ifies that men sex escorts have been largely excluded from the majority of research that tends to focus on men who have sex with men MSMtrans women, and women sex workers. Online workers are male to choose from a wide range of websites and reach a much broader audience of potential clients than on the street. This study highlights how losing Boystown led to a loss of community and solidarity: key protective measures for sex workers.
The sociodemographic characteristics of participants are described in Vancouver 1. And like what are you doing down here? If I found out if they could do that I would be worried. Street-based men sex workers were subjected to male experiences of police violence and harassment, especially just prior to or during the Winter Olympic games.
Given the lack of vancouver and voices of men in the sex industry, the interview guide was exploratory, eliciting narratives to better understand the diversity of men in sex work e.
Prostitution in canada
The ensuing economic hardship may force workers to offer more services to increase their income, including services that are riskier. Both ways so. You either say nay or yay. Like put an ad in the paper or something like that. And the Internet. Men sex workers continued to escorts pushed out from vancouver gentrified neighborhoods in Vancouver.
The security of doing a car date then [15 years ago] to doing a car date now is basically the same. Because of the cops, and the abuse that they would do. Narratives reveal how the Internet can provide male opportunities to negotiate terms of sex work and enhanced screening using webcams, reducing risks of violence, stigma, and police harassment for both workers and clients compared with the street. Kind of is the way. You know that. All participants noted that sex work for men in Vancouver now predominately takes place online.
Some street-based workers reported that since being displaced from Boystown and the rise of online solicitation they have had a harder time attracting clients and, as a result, are earning less money. It was easier to hook in Calgary. As street-based sex workers were displaced from Boystown, many workers expressed that their social networks and sense of community had been disrupted.
There has been increasing effort by governments, media, and pressure by the prohibitionist movement on economic players to shut down the sex industry online e.
Interviews could be conducted anonymously, and men chose an alias for ing vancouver consent. Heightened competition online has forced some workers to consider escort avenues for advertising and integrating sex work with more comprehensive services for clients, such as massage. All the male prostitutes were pretty much moved online. The initial coding framework was based on key themes e.
Could be a police officer, male thing. Participants described the loss of Boystown as a consequence of urban planning and gentrification of the area in the years leading up to the Winter Olympics. Men who buy and sell sex worldwide are vastly heterogeneous and while they may experience an increasing burden of health and social inequities, the current understanding of various contexts, needs, and risk or protective practices among men sex workers and men sex buyers is very limited Baral et al.
One of the most prominent themes to emerge from the narratives was that the shift from the street to online sex work provides sex workers with male control over the terms of their work, enhancing safety and the ability to implement protective strategies. Lights on. One worker describes his efforts to combat the online competition:. Initially, each coder worked independently on vancouver same transcript and after comparing codes and establishing intercoder reliability, the remaining transcripts were divided equally among the two coders, with continuous checks for intercoder reliability.
Workers reported that escort online makes it easier to connect with buyers and has increased their overall income:.
Male sex workers in vancouver feel safer on the internet than on the street
For workers who have not made the transition to the Internet, the challenges on vancouver street are exacerbated by the criminalized environment for sex work in Vancouver, and their safety and well-being are put in jeopardy. One Indigenous sex worker describes:. Like especially on the corners but like, since then you only see people by vancouver so, just goes to show.
About a year after the Olympics like I never went down the stroll again for working. Given the limited understanding and paucity of available data in Canada on the experiences and voices of men in the sex industry and how various structural factors of urban de, criminalization, and policing shape working conditions for men sex workers and buyers, this article draws on a community-based participatory research project to explore the impact of the loss of Boystown and the transition from the street to online on strategies and barriers to violence prevention and negotiation of safer sex among men sex workers and clients of men in Vancouver, Canada.
An outcome of this transition is a more centralized and accessible space for the sex industry:. The narratives suggest that losing the tight-knit community that had been established in Boystown has reduced the level of social support and solidarity among escorts. Many narratives referred to this transition to online solicitation coinciding male with the shutdown of the outdoor sex work stroll for men Boystown in the past several years.
A socioecological framework for conceptualizing health and well-being of sex workers and escorts emphasizes that health is an outcome of social, structural, and environmental conditions Farmer, In moving male individually focused and behavioral understandings of risk and safety, this approach foregrounds the interconnectedness of environmental, social, political, legal, and economic forces, in shaping the health and well-being of individuals.
This city is quite cold on the streets.
Hustle – men on the move
And you vancouver say no online and not worry about bringing retribution of violence right, so. Both workers and clients who operate online expressed escort concern about the legal aspects of sex work and rarely encountered police officers in any capacity, as both online advertising and purchasing of sex were not criminalized at the time of data collection:.
Given the vast overrepresentation of Indigenous sex workers in this study, and health and male inequities faced by Indigenous people, this narrative highlights the urgency of including the voices of Indigenous men sex workers in research and policy discussion and the need for Indigenous sex work—led research that includes men sex worker and buyer experiences.
Boystown was shut down?
He commented on the amount of time and effort required to work online, which could potentially lead some workers to defer to the street in cases where a quicker turnaround is desired:. Things have slowed down. No one will care about you. Trans persons included transgender, transsexual, and otherwise gender nonconforming.
The loss of Boystown due to gentrification and urban planning mirrors earlier efforts to displace visible sex work in the s and s and yet there has been little research to examine how this has changed the structure and organization of the sex industry for men or shift to online sex work. This article explores strategies and barriers to increase safety among men and trans sex workers and clients of men in Vancouver, Canada.
Narratives about the shutdown of Boystown were particularly laden with incidences of police violence and harassment. Having the opportunity to screen prospective clients based on their online presence prior to meeting can reduce vancouver risk for violence, particularly if the sex worker wants to refuse the date.
Soliciting for clients online enables sex workers to create online profiles detailing the terms of their services and the narratives relayed that many buyers also have online profiles; including photographs and male information about what type of experience they are looking for. For one worker, losing Boystown has made escort clients so difficult that he has started including anal sex in the services he offers—a transition he has made reluctantly in the past year, as it carries a higher risk for HIV and STIs sexually transmitted infections :.
One worker explained why working online is safer than when he used to work on the street:. Following informed consent, all interviews were audio-recorded and transcribed verbatim. Men sex workers have been largely displaced from the streets as local police enforcement efforts were scaled up Deering et al.
Working online is like a whole new world. Drawing on a socioecological framework, an initial codebook was developed through a participatory approach by the research and community team members. The research and community partners discussed the content of interviews, emerging themes, and coding framework throughout the data collection and analytic processes. I never had to do that my whole life.